Page 1 of 3 123 LastLast
Results 1 to 10 of 21

Thread: Tuning...from a different perspective

  1. #1
    Bradfo69's Avatar
    Bradfo69 is offline Pending BST Forum Purchases: $47,127,283.53
    Join Date
    Jul 2010
    Location
    Wilmington, DE
    Posts
    6,207

    Default Tuning...from a different perspective

    I seem to have developed a preoccupation with scanner tuning. Perhaps because I haven't actually begun to turn pots and thus far, have read a lot, studied Tim Walsh at TexLEM and stared at the ILDA test pattern on all of my projectors with great dismay. Whether it's CT6215's, DT 40 Wides, DT40 pros, or cheap 25k chinese scanners, NONE of them are perfect. Yet, there is a recurring theme on each set. And that is the blue circle is CONSISTENTLY outside the box. It's a circle (not oval). The box is a box. I'm not seeing undershoot or overshoot. It's just the circle is not inside the box. I know I really need to break out a screwdriver and do this but, I also don't have the identification of the various pots done yet with 100 percent certainty and, I know that is absolutely critical before I attempt to change anything.

    What my question is though, based on that, what image problems should I be experiencing? What, in my graphics or text, should I be seeing that's "wrong" when the blue circle is bigger than the box? I tend to think the graphics/text in most cases look pretty good. But, by the same token, I find I'm getting wigged out over a damn test pattern. Is there suddenly going to be an "AH HA!" moment once the tuning is done to such a degree that the blue circle is inside and just touching the square as it's supposed to? Or are graphics and text still going to look *pretty much* the same?

    I know there is a 12k pattern as well as a 30k pattern and, I'm using the 30k pattern included with LD2000. The software is all at set at 30k. Should I REALLY remain concerned with this or, save it for a LEM or something and pester sombebody there?
    Last edited by Bradfo69; 03-11-2012 at 20:05.

  2. #2
    Join Date
    Oct 2010
    Location
    Athens, Greece
    Posts
    1,930

    Default

    Have you tried to scan the 30k pattern at 35kpps or even 40kpps?
    Maybe the circle fits better in the box at higher speeds.

    I say, save it for a LEM. Maybe everyone sees it and tells you to stop worrying about it
    "its called character briggs..."

  3. #3
    Join Date
    Mar 2010
    Location
    Raleigh, NC
    Posts
    2,314

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by LaNeK779 View Post
    Have you tried to scan the 30k pattern at 35kpps or even 40kpps?
    Maybe the circle fits better in the box at higher speeds.

    I say, save it for a LEM. Maybe everyone sees it and tells you to stop worrying about it
    Here's my opinion...

    Circle outside the box is not all that bad depending on the frame source. If you are displaying hand optimized frames with point pulling then you need to tune them correctly. If you are displaying beam shows, computer generated shapes, abstracts, and traced images you are probably better off with the circle outside of the square. If the circle is outside of the square it means the scanners are more capable of correctly drawing a difficult shape but it will throw off images that use point pulling. I really think that the ILDA test pattern is largely irrelevant these days. Tuning scanners so that X & Y respond at the same speed is very important, though.

    It would be interesting to do some experiments with scanners tuned as hot as they can be vs tuned to the ILDA test pattern and see how they perform under different situations. I would be willing to bet Pangolin has done this so it would be interesting to get their take on it. Make it is something to ask them at FLEM.

  4. #4
    Bradfo69's Avatar
    Bradfo69 is offline Pending BST Forum Purchases: $47,127,283.53
    Join Date
    Jul 2010
    Location
    Wilmington, DE
    Posts
    6,207

    Default

    The OTHER point to this whole "tuning" thing is... now that I just got a projector with CT's, I'm EXPECTING to see something better than I have with DT40wides and thus far... I can't say I'm all that impressed. Maybe I'm expecting too much or, am not yet trained enough to know what to look for. The only reference I have at this point is to compare ILDA test patterns and, they're all pretty much the same. ("Wrong" but, the same nonetheless.)

  5. #5
    Join Date
    May 2006
    Location
    Native Floridian
    Posts
    3,145

    Default

    Gary pretty much hit the nail on the head in my opinion. If you're going to mainly do graphic shows with the projector then it is important to get it pretty close. If the circle is an oval then they are not running at the same speed. When I tune, I set the circle to just slightly exceed the square, I then flip over to the Laser Media test pattern to see if the retrace lines are dead on or not. If not, I'll alternate between the ilda test pattern and the laser media test pattern until the retrace lines in the laser media test pattern are correct. Then the scanners are definately running at the same speed.

    It would be interesting to do some experiments with scanners tuned as hot as they can be vs tuned to the ILDA test pattern and see how they perform under different situations.
    On the projector I'm working on, both scan heads are G-120 based, one set is running at 30K and the other is running about 12K. I set the output from pangolin to around 20K and ran a few shows, the 30K scan head is amazingly loud whereas the 12K scan head is quiet as a cat. The images displayed on the 30K scan head hit each point, as expected and the drawn images have sharp corners, the 12K scan head is not hitting all the points and the sharp corners are more rounded. I actually kinda like the output of the 12K side over the 30K side. May have to do some more playing around with this!

  6. #6
    Join Date
    Mar 2010
    Location
    Raleigh, NC
    Posts
    2,314

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by DZ View Post
    On the projector I'm working on, both scan heads are G-120 based, one set is running at 30K and the other is running about 12K. I set the output from pangolin to around 20K and ran a few shows, the 30K scan head is amazingly loud whereas the 12K scan head is quiet as a cat. The images displayed on the 30K scan head hit each point, as expected and the drawn images have sharp corners, the 12K scan head is not hitting all the points and the sharp corners are more rounded. I actually kinda like the output of the 12K side over the 30K side. May have to do some more playing around with this!
    Could you elaborate on this? You say one set is running at 30K and the other at 12K with Pangolin output set to 20K. Do you mean you tuned one set at 30K and the other at 12K and are running both at 20K? Or am I missing something?

  7. #7
    Join Date
    May 2006
    Location
    Native Floridian
    Posts
    3,145

    Default

    Yes, I should have been more clear, one set is TUNED to 30K while the other set is TUNED to 12K and I'm sending it a 20K signal.

  8. #8
    Join Date
    Feb 2007
    Location
    Delaware USA
    Posts
    794

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by DZ View Post
    Yes, I should have been more clear, one set is TUNED to 30K while the other set is TUNED to 12K and I'm sending it a 20K signal.
    There should be a lot of rounding on the 12K scanners with a 20k signal in my experience..

  9. #9
    mixedgas's Avatar
    mixedgas is offline Creaky Old Award Winning Bastard Technologist
    Infinitus Excellentia Ion Laser Dominatus
    Join Date
    May 2007
    Location
    A lab with some dripping water on the floor.
    Posts
    10,114

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by Bradfo69 View Post
    The OTHER point to this whole "tuning" thing is... now that I just got a projector with CT's, I'm EXPECTING to see something better than I have with DT40wides and thus far... I can't say I'm all that impressed. Maybe I'm expecting too much or, am not yet trained enough to know what to look for. The only reference I have at this point is to compare ILDA test patterns and, they're all pretty much the same. ("Wrong" but, the same nonetheless.)
    Where you'll see the difference is lifetime. I have old Cambridges made in 1995 I can still use. I have a set of DTs that was mainly a backup, have less then 40 hours on them, and have rotted bearings after two years in storage. The oil in the bearings jelled or evaporated. I know others who have the same problem with the bearings. So until DT switches to expensive ceramic bearings, Cambridges and Eye Magic are a better investment as far as I am concerned.

    I also know I can hit 56K small angle with the Cambridges hooked to a Turbotrack amp, or a DSP based amp, should I need to borrow one. I've seen two graphics shows run side by side off the same pair of 6800Hp scanners at 56K, it was a special demo version of Pangolin that can run two shows at once. I'd like to see a pair of clones do that.

    As Pangolin has switched over to "vector" mode in the newer products, tuning is a bit less of a issue, unless you are doing 3D wireframe or very tight logos, or need to overlay graphics. Hook those ASIAN scanners to my QM32 with the older "point dumping" software and I'll show you the difference.

    Also Cambridge still makes scanners for much larger mirrors, which is becoming a issue with diode array based systems.

    The ILDA pattern is not irrelevant, you still need to tune the scanners initially, and you can not do that on the factory "square wave" initial alignment, alone.

    Steve
    Last edited by mixedgas; 03-16-2012 at 18:08.

  10. #10
    Join Date
    Jun 2010
    Location
    Zweibrücken, Germany
    Posts
    605

    Default

    I just posted this yesterday on the EMS7000 thread, seems to fit well here too.

    Being the way I am, questioning things that don’t totally make sense to me, I researched a little more on the subject of the kpps/ILDA pattern question. Well it turns out that my speaker analogy was spot on and the ILDA pattern at best is a compromise made at a time when 60k scanning was somewhere in the far future. The bottom line of what I’ve found is that tuning scanners to reproduce the ILDA pattern as intended, just means that the scanner is tuned to reproduce the ILDA pattern, it therefore says nothing as to how well the scanners will reproduce other complex graphics at different scan speeds.

    The main thing that bothers me about the ILDA pattern is the fact that the scanned image is supposed to display the circle inside the square. This is actually a distorted output of the input signal where the square is in the circle. IMO this makes no sense whatsoever. For my understanding of positioning systems or PID controls, output should equal input. Scanners tuned in this manner, must be prone to also distort other complex images.

    It seems to me that when the ILDA pattern was developed someone leaned towards the static test pattern of a television which has no moving mass, thus the static image. IMO for tuning a moving mass a dynamic signal, covering a broader bandwidth of a given frequency range would much better linearise output over a broader range of scan speeds. As with speakers, the goal is to be linear in output over a given frequency spectrum.

    I don’t know… just my 2 cents worth?

    P.S. If you're going too do a show with ILDA patterns then you're all set to go, great show dude...

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •