
Originally Posted by
Solarfire
I just posted this yesterday on the EMS7000 thread, seems to fit well here too.
Being the way I am, questioning things that don’t totally make sense to me, I researched a little more on the subject of the kpps/ILDA pattern question. Well it turns out that my speaker analogy was spot on and the ILDA pattern at best is a compromise made at a time when 60k scanning was somewhere in the far future. The bottom line of what I’ve found is that tuning scanners to reproduce the ILDA pattern as intended, just means that the scanner is tuned to reproduce the ILDA pattern, it therefore says nothing as to how well the scanners will reproduce other complex graphics at different scan speeds.
The main thing that bothers me about the ILDA pattern is the fact that the scanned image is supposed to display the circle inside the square. This is actually a distorted output of the input signal where the square is in the circle. IMO this makes no sense whatsoever. For my understanding of positioning systems or PID controls, output should equal input. Scanners tuned in this manner, must be prone to also distort other complex images.
It seems to me that when the ILDA pattern was developed someone leaned towards the static test pattern of a television which has no moving mass, thus the static image. IMO for tuning a moving mass a dynamic signal, covering a broader bandwidth of a given frequency range would much better linearise output over a broader range of scan speeds. As with speakers, the goal is to be linear in output over a given frequency spectrum.
I don’t know… just my 2 cents worth?
P.S. If you're going too do a show with ILDA patterns then you're all set to go, great show dude...