Looking for a new power meter. Something a bit robust that I can use in the field.
I'm drawn to the Thorlabs PM310D.
http://www.thorlabs.com/newgrouppage...4216&pn=PM310D
What is everyone else using?
Best,
Greg
Looking for a new power meter. Something a bit robust that I can use in the field.
I'm drawn to the Thorlabs PM310D.
http://www.thorlabs.com/newgrouppage...4216&pn=PM310D
What is everyone else using?
Best,
Greg
Look, I love Tlabs, but under no circumstances buy that product. When I was a FSE we often were at issue with customers who used those, vs our NIST traceable power meters. We would see errors of 20-30% on the Tlabs product. We urged several customers to return those, and they did. The repeatability was good, but the absolute calibration was way off.
Of a 4 unit sample, from multiple batches, 3 had serious discrepancies.
Steve
Last edited by mixedgas; 07-15-2014 at 12:05.
Qui habet Christos, habet Vitam!
I should have rented the space under my name for advertising.
When I still could have...
I have no experience with the Thorlabs unit, but for less than that price you can get the Coherent Powermax LM-10, which is great for using on site. USB only, so it packs very compact, nice and rugged, annual recalibration from Coherent is priced very reasonably. The big disadvantage is that you have to have a laptop or windows based tablet to use it, but I really can't think of any time I've gone out to a customer site and haven't brought a computer with me anyway. You can buy a lot of lab snacks with the hundred bucks you save.
Steve...
I thought the calibration data was stored in each sensor, not the PM100D, and the sensors are NIST traceable.
So it shouldn't have been a problem; can you elaborate a little?
What exact head was used?
Regards,
Dan
- There is no such word as "can't" -
- 60% of the time it works every time -
http://www.amazon.com/AixiZ-Sper-Sci...er+power+meter
how about this? 200.00
Steve,
PM not received. Can you check/resend?
Cheers,
Dan
- There is no such word as "can't" -
- 60% of the time it works every time -
It depends what you want to use the power meter for.
For checking the performance of a laser projector’s output, use a meter with a thermal detector head. These have a fairly broadband response, meaning they can be used to be measure the total power output of several beams of differing wavelengths simultaneously, and are available to measure high power outputs of several watts or more.
If you want to check a laser beam to determine safe exposure for an audience scanning application, standard thermal detectors are generally not suitable; they are too slow to react, and don’t have the resolution (unless you use one of the high sensitivity devices, but the maximum power they can measure will be limited to typically less than a watt, and they still have a (relatively) slow response time).
For measuring exposure levels, the better option to get an instantaneous reading is to use a photodiode based detector. These provide the sensitivity and resolution to measure what will be in the mW region. The downside is that they will only give an accurate reading for one wavelength at a time, so it makes measuring a multicolour beam more difficult.
The simple thing to remember is :
Measure Power = Thermal Detector
Measure Exposure = PD Detector
Given that some people will want to measure both these things, then buying meter that can accept multiple detectors is something to consider.
As far as the Thorlabs kit you mentioned is concerned. I have no experience with that specific detector, but do have some good recent experiences with the same meter and some other detectors of theirs. Maybe the problems with the calibration have been resolved.
I had a similar problem with another major manufacturer’s meter/detector combination. One detector type was fine, but the other caused me lots of problems giving a consistent >15% error, even after being recalibrated by the manufacturer twice. I know this sort of experience does knock your confidence in the manufacturer.
I have a selection of meters from Coherent, Ophir, ILT and others, and each has its own benefits / nuances.
James
Laser Safety
https://www.lvroptical.com
https://www.facebook.com/LaserSafety
- Laser Show Safety Training & Audience Scanning Workshops.
- Effects Assessment, and Realtime MPE Measurement
- Pangolin PASS System Integrator