Just a follow-up . .
Those Surplus Shed FS bounce mirrors arrived and I just did a quick reflectivity test and they measure in at 90% on the 638nm diode I used for testing. That's not the nice 98% you'd want in a projector steering mirror, but its still better and cheaper than the 82% Do-It-Yourself approach.
Oh, and after 2 weeks after mounting those original DIY mirrors, I remeasured and they are still have 82% reflectivity. (They have been sitting indoors in a room with 80% humidity.)
I never did get all the layers of paint off of the other mirror I was trying to strip, but with a stack of the Surplus Shed mirrors sitting here, I don't have a need to keep messing with it.
-David
"Help, help, I'm being repressed!"