Page 7 of 27 FirstFirst ... 3456789101117 ... LastLast
Results 61 to 70 of 264

Thread: To the laser show software companies

  1. #61
    Join Date
    May 2006
    Location
    Native Floridian
    Posts
    3,133

    Default

    watching pretty lasers dancing to Britney Spears
    I know Thanksgiving (U.S.A. Holiday) is over, but I'd like to say that I'm thankful that there are no free B.S. shows. I'd probably have to burn the QM2K and gouge out my eyes if I ever accidentally ran a B.S. show on my QM2K.

    Sure, everyone could spend a bunch of money on Pangolin stuff and have 100 shows to watch. But then what?
    Well, actually with the 300,000 free frames that comes with it, you can put together some nice material.

    Yea, maybe the shows suck and are just some animations spinning aroud.
    You know, everyone's different, so I can't tell you what you will and will not like. Though I'd like to share a bit of personal experience. I'm a big fan of graphic shows, especially when they are very well put together. I recently watch a Metallica show in a Planetarium that was using AVI's Omniscan, a projector that projects 180 by 360 degrees. The show was outstanding, I could have watched it another dozen times without getting up. I stayed for the next show, Pink Floyd. I'm a huge fan of Pink Floyd, as my avatar might suggest. Apparently, the theater decided to program the Pink Floyd show in-house. It was aweful, it was just very bad. I got up and left before it was half way over. There's a difference.

  2. #62
    Join Date
    Dec 2006
    Location
    Pflugerville, TX, USA
    Posts
    1,977

    Default

    DZ, I am sorry to say that you totally missed the point.

  3. #63
    Join Date
    May 2006
    Location
    Native Floridian
    Posts
    3,133

    Default

    DZ, I am sorry to say that you totally missed the point.
    You know what Carmangary, you too damn thick to understand my point anyway. You've used this thread to attack the professional companies out there that make laser show software. For one you come out saying that your software is going to blow everything else out of the water. Let see it, put your money where your mouth is. Let us be the judge of that. You also go on to say that these companies are greedy. What would you think if you boss hired someone tomorrow to do your job for free because its a fun hobby for him. You do understand that the reason Pangolin, Mamba, etc charge money for thier software is because its thier livelihood, they have bills to pay and families to feed. Plus, if you put out a piece of software today, will you be there 10 years from now supporting many hundreds or thousands of clients? Dealing with all thier software issues and writing updates, all for free? I've said before I think its great what your trying to do, and have even offered help and ideas, but your attacking is just such a damn turn off.

  4. #64
    Join Date
    Dec 2006
    Location
    Pflugerville, TX, USA
    Posts
    1,977

    Default

    Honestly, I don't care anymore.

  5. #65
    Join Date
    Dec 2007
    Location
    Texas
    Posts
    98

    Default

    Carmangary,

    Can you post the link to your software that lets people preview laser shows. I don't remember which thread it was in before. Also, does it sync to WAV or music files?

  6. #66
    Join Date
    Dec 2006
    Location
    Pflugerville, TX, USA
    Posts
    1,977

    Default

    I deleted the IldaViewer application from the board a week or two ago. It is no longer available. But, another guy posted one that you can use. It is in the laser frames forum.

  7. #67
    Join Date
    Jan 2006
    Location
    Charleston, SC
    Posts
    2,147,489,554

    Arrow

    Quote Originally Posted by carmangary View Post
    Yea, good shows are hard to make. But, I'd rather have 100 free amateur shows to music that I like that I can watch while I drink beer in my room than just a few professional show to some music I don't even care about.
    Who is going to make those 100 amateur shows? Other hobbyists? Then what's to say they won't *also* use music you don't like?

    You haven't even looked at the shows that come with Pangolin and you're already bashing them because you think they come with music you don't care about. How can you complain if you don't even know what music is used?
    Sure, everyone could spend a bunch of money on Pangolin stuff and have 100 shows to watch.
    No, not everyone. I understand that it's expensive and that not everyone can afford it. But it *is* a great way to start. You get some fun things to watch while you learn how to create shows. Then you get a lot of frames to use to create your own shows. Eventually though, you'll have to learn how to draw your own frames if you want more shows. But by that time you'll either be well on your way to learning how to use your software, or you'll be in a position to purchase more frames (if you're in the business of producing laser shows.)
    Are there any shows to KMFDM or Ministry in that bag of shows? If not, then they're all worthless to me.
    So those are the only 2 groups you ever listen to? You must be the most narrow minded person on the planet then.

    Besides, for the beam shows at least, you can play several different pieces of music and the shows still look pretty cool.

    As to your comment that they're all "worthless", well, I think it's very premature to make such a claim before you've even seen what is in the shows.
    I'd rather spend time creating my own shows to music I like than watching pretty lasers dancing to Britney Spears or whatever they have.
    First, there's no "Britney Spears". There are some classical numbers, some classic rock numbers, a few pop tunes from the 80's, some more modern rock numbers, a few country songs, some Euro-dance numbers, and even some stuff I've never heard before.

    If you don't like anything in that eclectic mix of music, then by all means create your own shows. Perhaps you are one of the few people that are gifted when it comes to being able to hand draw things. But I haven't seen you touting any ILDA frames or animations that you've done so far, which leads me to believe that you haven't actually done much work in that area. I suggest that before you trivialize the show creation process, you try to build a 5 minute, all-original show yourself.
    And, I'd be happy to share whatever I come up with with others for free
    Just as most members here are willing to share files they've created. I've created two entire shows (one consisting entirely of original abstracts) and put them up on the FTP server for people to download. That's sort of expected in the hobbyist field... But none of the "hobbyist" shows I've seen come close to the entertainment value of the professional shows that come with Pangolin.
    so that maybe they can give me their Thrill Kill Kult shows.
    But that's not "KMFDM or Ministry", so by your own words those shows would be useless to you.
    Yea, maybe the shows suck and are just some animations spinning aroud. I'm cool with that. If I drink enough beer it will all be cool.
    Well, then think about how much cooler the Pangolin shows (which do *not* suck) will be when you watch them.
    If you're in this as a ways to make money then you probably don't understand my point of view because you're only interested in a handful of really really good shows.
    You're wrong. I'm not in the business, and I don't make money on my lasers. (Quite the opposite!) In fact, *most* people here are firmly in the hobbyist camp. But like them, I nevertheless appreciate a good laser show. I *enjoy* watching good laser shows. (So do my friends and neighbors!) And I am very happy that I have a good collection of shows that I can watch whenever I want to geek out with my lasers. It's sort of like having a large DVD collection. More is better, because after a while the same old movie gets booring. But if you've got a wide selection, you can be entertained night after night.
    But, if you are in it for the cool lights and music then maybe you can see what I am getting at.
    I am *absolutely* in it for the cool lights and music. In fact, one of the coolest things about Pangolin (in my opinion) is the AVS Laser Visualiser plug in for Winamp. It's basically a fully-automatic, beat-syncronized, live laser show that changes with the music. It's as awesome as the standard AVS visualizer that you have on the screen, but with the added bonus that it's coming from your laser projector! You can customize the presets, build your own presets, and change them on the fly. I honestly believe that it ALONE is cool enough to warrant the purchase of a Pangolin LD-2000 system.

    Oh, and you can use it with whatever music you want (including "KMFDM or Ministry"). You can even use it with the line-in jack on your computer's sound card, so if you want to play your guitar (or piano, or other instrument of choice) to make your own music, you can *still* have a custom lasershow playing along at the same time.
    I am done discussing this because it is going no where.
    Part of the reason it's going nowhere is because you have a habit of replying to a well-structured comment with a kurt sentence or two. That's not a discussion, it's a blow off. And if you continue to blow people off (after first ASKING for their advice), then people will stop offering it to you. That's why DZ snapped back at you. (Personally, I agree with his sentiment.)

    When people don't agree with you, rather than at least listening to what they have to say and maybe trying to reach some middle ground, you simply turn them off and go your own way. While that's certainly your perogative, it can get mighty lonely down that road. Are you really better off going it alone? And if you say "yes", then one has to wonder what you hope to gain from the forums here...

    Adam
    Last edited by buffo; 01-16-2008 at 09:58.

  8. #68
    Join Date
    Dec 2006
    Location
    Pflugerville, TX, USA
    Posts
    1,977

    Default

    Well, I had a long response but it got wiped out when I accidently hit the backspace key at the wrong time.

    But to summarize, I am not bashing anything put out by Pangolin. I haven't seen any of their stuff but I expect it is all top notch. But, they are not a hobbyist outfit (and there is nothing wrong with that) so their products are overkill (and overpriced) for my needs. Even if I was willing to pay for them I would still have compatibility issues with my friends who can't afford their stuff. A lot of stuff has been said in this thread but that is the main point of it all. And the response from Pangolin was that they don't want to allow cross compatibility at this point so that's pretty much the end of that. I acknowledge that they have the hobby LaFreak package but it omits the shows (and the frames?) so that's not all that appealing - especially without an SDK or API.

    I'm trying to help open doors to the people who currently don't have the means to get into this hobby. I'm only offering a part of the solution, but I hope the other parts will follow. My points are definitely valid, even if they are a little extreme.

    It may take awhile for me to get my software where it needs to be and it may take awhile before people get into making shows and exchanging them but it will happen. At that time, don't feel the need to join in and share - just stick to whatever you are doing now and ignore me.



    Quote Originally Posted by Buffo View Post
    Who is going to make those 100 amateur shows? Other hobbyists? Then what's to say they won't *also* use music you don't like?

    You haven't even looked at the shows that come with Pangolin and you're already bashing them because you think they come with music you don't care about. How can you complain if you don't even know what music is used?

    No, not everyone. I understand that it's expensive and that not everyone can afford it. But it *is* a great way to start. You get some fun things to watch while you learn how to create shows. Then you get a lot of frames to use to create your own shows. Eventually though, you'll have to learn how to draw your own frames if you want more shows. But by that time you'll either be well on your way to learning how to use your software, or you'll be in a position to purchase more frames (if you're in the business of producing laser shows.)

    So those are the only 2 groups you ever listen to? You must be the most narrow minded person on the planet then.

    Besides, for the beam shows at least, you can play several different pieces of music and the shows still look pretty cool.

    As to your comment that they're all "worthless", well, I think it's very premature to make such a claim before you've even seen what is in the shows.

    First, there's no "Britney Spears". There are some classical numbers, some classic rock numbers, a few pop tunes from the 80's, some more modern rock numbers, a few country songs, some Euro-dance numbers, and even some stuff I've never heard before.

    If you don't like anything in that eclectic mix of music, then by all means create your own shows. Perhaps you are one of the few people that are gifted when it comes to being able to hand draw things. But I haven't seen you touting any ILDA frames or animations that you've done so far, which leads me to believe that you haven't actually done much work in that area. I suggest that before you trivialize the show creation process, you try to build a 5 minute, all-original show yourself.

    Just as most members here are willing to share files they've created. I've created two entire shows (one consisting entirely of original abstracts) and put them up on the FTP server for people to download. That's sort of expected in the hobbyist field... But none of the "hobbyist" shows I've seen come close to the entertainment value of the professional shows that come with Pangolin.

    But that's not "KMFDM or Ministry", so by your own words those shows would be useless to you.

    Well, then think about how much cooler the Pangolin shows (which do *not* suck) will be when you watch them.

    You're wrong. I'm not in the business, and I don't make money on my lasers. (Quite the opposite!) In fact, *most* people here are firmly in the hobbyist camp. But like them, I nevertheless appreciate a good laser show. I *enjoy* watching good laser shows. (So do my friends and neighbors!) And I am very happy that I have a good collection of shows that I can watch whenever I want to geek out with my lasers. It's sort of like having a large DVD collection. More is better, because after a while the same old movie gets booring. But if you've got a wide selection, you can be entertained night after night.

    I am *absolutely* in it for the cool lights and music. In fact, one of the coolest things about Pangolin (in my opinion) is the AVS Laser Visualiser plug in for Winamp. It's basically a fully-automatic, beat-syncronized, live laser show that changes with the music. It's as awesome as the standard AVS visualizer that you have on the screen, but with the added bonus that it's coming from your laser projector! You can customize the presets, build your own presets, and change them on the fly. I honestly believe that it ALONE is cool enough to warrant the purchase of a Pangolin LD-2000 system.

    Oh, and you can use it with whatever music you want (including "KMFDM or Ministry"). You can even use it with the line-in jack on your computer's sound card, so if you want to play your guitar (or piano, or other instrument of choice) to make your own music, you can *still* have a custom lasershow playing along at the same time.

    Part of the reason it's going nowhere is because you have a habit of replying to a well-structured comment with a kurt sentence or two. That's not a discussion, it's a blow off. And if you continue to blow people off (after first ASKING for their advice), then people will stop offering it to you. That's why DZ snapped back at you. (Personally, I agree with his sentiment.)

    When people don't agree with you, rather than at least listening to what they have to say and maybe trying to reach some middle ground, you simply turn them off and go your own way. While that's certainly your perogative, it can get mighty lonely down that road. Are you really better off going it alone? And if you say "yes", then one has to wonder what you hope to gain from the forums here...

    Adam

  9. #69
    Join Date
    Apr 2006
    Location
    Miami, FL
    Posts
    3,590

    Default

    I understand what you’re saying, I see your point of view... but honestly, if you cant make something that is better, cheaper, more efficient, or at least some of those, then why raise all this ruckus?

    I see this all the time with high end audio makers, someone that knows about electronics starts ranting and raving on how the latest $5000 amplifier has $30 in components in it and therefore should be sold for no more than $50 etc...

    If you really do possess the programming skills and hardware design skills to create your own laser show software and hardware i look forward to seeing it (seriously, not trying to be sarcastic)

    the laser show enthusiast community is pretty small, and the whole industry is pretty small since people are a bit less amused by the pretty light and lines when they can go buy an LCD projector at best buy for $500 and run some win amp visualizations for free... which for most people is just as satisfying and a whole lot easier...

    Most of the laser shows community is made up of geeks/nerds and tinkerers that enjoy building these things and get a sense of satisfaction from watching our creation come to life...

    And companies like pangolin which are in the business of selling hardware and software to commercial laserists really doesn’t need your or my approval to exist… because there is a market and a demand and they satisfy it… now, we, as enthusiasts want to be able to do this stuff on the side or even just at home for our own personal enjoyment and pangolin tries to help us as much as they really can… they develop entry level stuff, they discount hardware and software for us, and even listen to the community as far as application development (some of which really has little commercial value, which is what companies are all about, creating things with commercial value)… so I think you may be being a little unfair to them directing any hate in their direction… as a programmer you should know that creating complex software capable of what their software does, along with their hardware, is no easy task... and the prices they charge I think are more than fair since most of the commercial users of said hardware/software will easily make that money back after a few shows... I know the laser shows down here at the Miami Meuseum of Science are usually packed (and most are not even that good)...

    Please, do use your knowledge to create something great (because good is the enemy of great after all ) and bring it to the community to provide us another means of accomplishing what we have all set up to do… make pretty pictures & patters with some of the most amazing light sources on earth!

  10. #70
    Join Date
    Dec 2006
    Location
    Pflugerville, TX, USA
    Posts
    1,977

    Default

    Well, I AM creating something. It's called Spaghetti and will be free. My benchmark is Mamba Black. So expect something as good or better.

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •