Hello!
There arenīt exists realy 200mW CW ~660nm Diodes with these beam specs. Thatīs the point.But I also havenīt said that they donīt can do 200-250mW after optics for a while.
Yes, the Marconi Lasers done from 200-250mW, but how long? Much people here are angry becouse the modules died after a while. They die with 2 reasons: 1.) The diodes are runs overspec , and 2.) The driver will give peaks to the diodes which come from the powersupply,if you switch on and off your projector.Why does the most "good" lasers, and all chinese DPSS have a input delay? Not only for fun.
There exists a 640 (642)nm laserdiode, with 150mW CW power, from opnext, which has the same Beamdata than the 660nm Diodes. Arround 2mm <1mrad with good optics.
But they cost much more money than the 660nm Diodes,...
Greetings,
Phil
I think what Phil is trying to say is that there are not available diodes for any reasonable price with good beam specs. There are not really good diodes that produce over 200mW of red for a reasonable beam size and specs.
As for the meathod to shrink the beam, I would like to see that as it should not be possible to increase the brightness of the beam while maintaining the same power and divergence.
Please let me reiterate that the information I am providing is from a manufacturer, not from me... This has taken place many times before and has been discussed in great detail when I first introduced these almost a year ago to another forum.
Please see DrLava's roundup showing the 'Phazor' diode... It is not as good as the Open Cans, and I never claimed it is, especially not on all-out max power, but it is an OEM diode that comes real close, and is specced for 200mW CW.
Please let me reiterate that the information I am providing is from a manufacturer, not from me... This has taken place many times before and has been discussed in great detail when I first introduced these almost a year ago to another forum.
Please see DrLava's roundup showing the 'Phazor' diode... It is not as good as the Open Cans, and I never claimed it is, especially not on all-out max power, but it is an OEM diode that comes real close, and is specced for 200mW CW.
There was not datasheet available for these ever since they became available, unfortunately...
--DDL
P.S. Would anyone know the proposed spec for the 22X Open Can diodes? Perhaps the manufacturer's stated specification is incorrect/inaccurate.
Hello!
There arenīt exists 200mW CW models with this data! All Companys who declare the Diodes with small emitter and max. arround 10/20 degree angle of the emitter as FALSE! Look for example at Aixiz. They sell a diode "200mW cw and 350mW pulse". Exact the same data,datasheet as the 130mW CW 350mW pulse diode from Mitsubishi.So the Company declare it false. Also the diodes what you have, 100%ly.
The open can types are Mitsubishis, the datasheet says 150mW CW and 400mW pulse.
Greetings,
Phil
Hello!
There arenīt exists 200mW CW models with this data! All Companys who declare the Diodes with small emitter and max. arround 10/20 degree angle of the emitter as FALSE! Look for example at Aixiz. They sell a diode "200mW cw and 350mW pulse". Exact the same data,datasheet as the 130mW CW 350mW pulse diode from Mitsubishi.So the Company declare it false. Also the diodes what you have, 100%ly.
The open can types are Mitsubishis, the datasheet says 150mW CW and 400mW pulse.
Greetings,
Phil
You are correct Phil. daedal, maybe it would be wise to listen to him there are only a few manufacturers of red laser diodes and their specs are known. If you are going to sell a module at 200mW rating you should consider using the best diode available the LDOC diode or its Mitsu canned counterpart. however if you have a 1000+ hour warranty guarantee with free replacement then you can use whatever diode you wish
I truly appreciate this and hope everyone understands that it is not my intention to refute anyone's opinions... Dr.Lava, I recognize that you have the largest data set available from these diodes, as well as others, and appreciate your input on this.
The 'claim' that this is a 200mW diode was not initiated by me, but I bought them as such, and paid for them as such. Unfortunately, not all salesmen/saleswomen are honest, and perhaps I was provided diodes that are not as promised. As a result, I apologize, and again, I will be willing to provide diodes for testing should someone be willing to test them out again. I will conduct an age test for these units at 200mW CW in the module I provide without any external cooling. I will set up a small mount and measure the power over a period of time, all the while recording all the information I can get my hands on. I am not doubting anyone, but I wanted to have solid info before I go screaming at the 'manufacturer'
Let me explain that to all those who have asked me for prices on these units, I have offered 3 different diodes that anyone can choose from:
- These closed can OEM diodes (I mentioned they are 200mW CW diodes, and as such I will take that claim back).
- The open can diodes which are readily available and very affordable.
- The closed can long die red diodes from 6X BluRay sleds.
I will add to the list, Closed Can Long Die diodes from 4X BluRay sleds as I do have some of these available as well...
Any suggestions/comments/objections are most welcome as usual;
DDL
Yikes! 7? That must have some massive losses due to these optics!
According to the guy that put it together, no. Losses were present, but not a significant factor. Cost of the optics, on the other hand, *was* a significant factor, not to mention the high cost of the diode itself. At the time it was decided that it was not worth pursuing.
FLEM you say? Maitland?
Yeah - they have an art center there. Not sure how booked up it is, but I think I can get it for under a hundred bucks. Going to call them this afternoon. (Just waiting for contact info.)
Originally Posted by Phritzler
Hello!
There arenīt exists realy 200mW CW ~660nm Diodes with these beam specs.
You are correct. They require external optics. However, there *ARE* diodes that produce 250 mw of 660 nm red reliably. I have a pair of Maxyz modules that have close to 500 hours on them. Running just fine.
Yes, the Marconi Lasers done from 200-250mW, but how long? Much people here are angry becouse the modules died after a while.
You are correct in that a lot of Maxyz modules have failed. However, the primary reason is due to back reflection, not overdriving or any problems with the driver. (And yes, I know that most Maxyz modules *are* being overdriven.) Still, I've been running the same set in my projector for nearly 2 years now without any problems whatsoever. The key is that once I had them installed and aligned, I didn't mess with them ever again.
Another big issue with the Maxyz modules is that if you accidentally ground the diode, you kill it. This is why they have a rubber boot over the output aperture. I watched a PL member kill a maxyz module by trying to adjust the focus on the primary lens with a metal screwdriver. The shaft touched the housing of the module (outside of the rubber boot), and POOF! That was the end of that diode...
There exists a 640 (642)nm laserdiode, with 150mW CW power, from opnext, which has the same Beamdata than the 660nm Diodes. Arround 2mm <1mrad with good optics.
And they are quite expensive. There is also a 350 mw 635 nm red diode that both MechEng3 and Uncle Worm have been experimenting with. Given the correct set of optics, they've been able to get the divergence down to 1 mrad, and the beam diameter to between 3 and 4 mm. But again, the *cost* of this setup is prohibitive. (Remember the 7 element optical train I mentioned above? This is what it was for.)
Originally Posted by Laser Ben
I think what Phil is trying to say is that there are not available diodes for any reasonable price with good beam specs. There are not really good diodes that produce over 200mW of red for a reasonable beam size and specs.
If you stick with the stock optics that come with the diode, I agree with you. However, as MechEng3 has demonstrated, it *is* possible to improve the beam quality dramatically by experimenting with external optics. This is expensive and time-consuming, but the results are quite impressive. Mike has been trying to generate some interest among the members here to continue the experiments along this line, but so far no one else seems willing to tinker with it. And since he's busy working on a home-brew DPSS blue design right now, he's not working on the reds anymore. (A question of priorities, you see.) But there is more that can be done to tame the beam that just taking whatever you can get out of the stock optics.
Originally Posted by Phritzler
There arenīt exists 200mW CW models with this data! All Companys who declare the Diodes with small emitter and max. arround 10/20 degree angle of the emitter as FALSE!
I suggest you contact Uncle Worm directly and have him send you the specs on the diodes he was working with. They are *very* expensive, but they have a very small emitter and are spec'd for power levels well above 200 mw. Likewise, MechEng3 has other information on some 635 nm diodes with narrow emitters, and he has tested them himself to verify the information claimed on the data sheet.
OK the red scene is good and a lot of room to deal with unwilling beams at a power cost. I had a setup that was FAC microlensed first off. The FAC had a coating that was broadband and not optimised for 635/660nm. This was utilised to help tame the fast axis. Then a cylinder lens assembly was to continue the job. All is good to this point. Now you are left with a very wide red strip of coherent light. So on to the next steps...slow axis. A pair of cylinder lenses again were used to help tame this. At this point you are getting close. Now you need to direct the beam into yet another lens to repair the beam again from a spot point to a hopefully no-too-divergent beam. Then you can start to move things around a bit to see if things get any better.
The cylinder lenses are not cheap. Edmond optics does not have them. I have one set and they are in use. I will give you a starting point should you venture this approach.....
one each
PCV 10mm X 7mm X 6mm FL
PCX 10mm X 6mm X 6mmFL
PCX 10mm X 12mm X 20mmFL
The FAC lens is a .75mm broadband unit
You are the only one that can make your dreams come true....and the only one that can stop them...A.M. Dietrich