Page 6 of 8 FirstFirst ... 2345678 LastLast
Results 51 to 60 of 78

Thread: Commercial NON Varienced laser shows

  1. #51
    Join Date
    Apr 2006
    Location
    Miami, FL
    Posts
    3,590

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by allthatwhichis View Post
    I am not worried about you getting sued; The authorities, whoever they are that are not bothering to inspect you currently, will be investigating you after this hypothetical blinding by the high powered pointer. They will want to see your varienced projector just because it was in the same place as someone getting blinded by the fool with the "pointer". If you have a varience, in this instance, the authorities will look at your paperwork, and know you are a safe operator; if you don't have a varience, who knows what they will do to you and this is assuming everyone knows there was a fool with a pointer. My point is a varience is not useless just because you know you are not a fool; there are fools out there, and some of them have high powered hand held lasers. Which will bring the authorities to you...

    That is not saying the system is not stupid, but it what is in place; if you want to change the game you have to start by playing it by the rules.
    i am not getting sued because i am not doing any shows for money, or in public for that matter, and obviously you gotta pay to play as they say... so you have to have them to do shows, fine, but I would not feel any safer knowing a projector/venue is varianced if the person running the show has no idea what they are doing...

    you can have all the paperwork done, hand the keys over to some deedeedee operator that might decide, hey wouldn't it be cool if the projector were pointing down! and there goes your liability protection out the window

    the argument is kind of an endless loop,

    do you need a variance if you are doing a show legally: yes
    are they fundamentally stupid: yes
    are there better ways of doing it: yes, but nobody seems to really care to do anything about it
    will a variance actually protect you from liability: unknown, I am willing to bet not

  2. #52
    Join Date
    Apr 2006
    Location
    Miami, FL
    Posts
    3,590

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by mixedgas View Post
    hrmm, some of those seem pretty crazy, eye damage from a 2mW HeNe? seriously? some people complaining about temporary eye damage after a .5mW hene hit them? huh?

    this one was really funny

    Reference: 33
    Summary: Temporary sore eyes following laser show
    Description: Person was visiting a museum where they saw a 30 minute laser demonstration. Upon leaving, both observed they had red, bloodshot eyes. Complained of irritation and sore eyes. Medical treatment was not sought.
    uh... laser injury? no way that dude was high lol
    Last edited by flecom; 11-09-2009 at 20:18.

  3. #53
    Join Date
    Oct 2006
    Location
    Central Florida
    Posts
    7,067

    Lightbulb

    Quote Originally Posted by flecom View Post
    you can have all the paperwork done, hand the keys over to some deedeedee operator that might decide, hey wouldn't it be cool if the projector were pointing down! and there goes your liability protection out the window
    That makes the person handing the keys over a fool for not knowing his operator. I would think a person who went through all the work and frustration to get their projector varienced would know the qualifications of their operator.

    I plan on doing public shows with my projector... some day... but not until it is varienced. That is the process. It is like my job. I follow processes I think are foolish and waste time, we all do or have at some job; why, because the person paying me tells me that is the process I have to follow. I can work to change the processes by showing their inefficency and a better way... but I still have to follow their process.

    For now, I display my projector to friends and at LEMs. I have pulled some pannels off the Kvant to work on the safety features so I can then work on the paperwork that I hope I don't have to show anyone. Guess it is also like insurance... which we all hate at some point.

  4. #54
    Join Date
    Apr 2006
    Location
    Miami, FL
    Posts
    3,590

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by allthatwhichis View Post
    That makes the person handing the keys over a fool for not knowing his operator. I would think a person who went through all the work and frustration to get their projector varienced would know the qualifications of their operator.
    hrmm, you would be surprised then

  5. #55
    mixedgas's Avatar
    mixedgas is offline Creaky Old Award Winning Bastard Technologist
    Infinitus Excellentia Ion Laser Dominatus
    Join Date
    May 2007
    Location
    A lab with some dripping water on the floor.
    Posts
    10,070

    Default

    Yes, I can, I will videotape the show in a high risk environment. There is a hole in the projector mask for it.


    quote:
    and again, with little to no enforcement, what difference does it make? if you get sued and have a variance, the lawyers are probably going to laugh at it... they wont be suing your projector, they will be suing YOU[/QUOTE]

    Your very naive....

    I can't help it your local government doesn't do its job. But elsewhere in the country, it does work.

    Risk mitigation, damage mitigation, and avoiding a meet with a US Attorney if a incident did happen.

    I can tell you've never worked for a amusement park or a major tour, a variance is a legal requirement and you WILL meet the requirements.

    So Joe Blow's bar doesn't care, or FlyBy Night's rave doesn't care. The folks who pay the big money do. The insurer you hire will care. Since the lawyers sue everyone remotely connected to a incident, the folks who hire you should care. If you have insurance, and they find you didn't pull a permit, your on your own in a incident. They will hire a expert to mitigate damages. Case in point:

    A few months ago I flew to the scene of a fire. Based on my field of work at the university, I was considered a expert in my field. The opposing side had two professionals tearing the building apart looking for a cause. They were cutting into the walls with a sawzall and looking at every wire, every GFI, even the placement of paper on the workbench. Smoke patterns pointed to a specific spot as the start. 200,000$ was at stake, and they smelled a easy target, with respect to my client's gear. I took me about a day to prove them wrong, that a operator poured solvent into a power supply, which ignited improperly stored metal powder in the lab. The operator left the building with the gear running on a weekend. Boom. Major fire at a public building occupied by a hundred or so people.

    Two days of my time helped save that small company,and 10 jobs, as they were self insured. What really saved them was taking a photo of every unit before they shipped. It gave me the nail in the coffin ,for the other guy's theory, which was bad wiring. They could not afford UL and CE on every custom item they make. But the paperwork trail saved them.

    And again, I dare you to set up at a large university or corporation that has a safety department and let them find out you do not have a variance. Or run in Arizona where the DPS WILL notify radiation safety and you will be fined or your equipment seized.

    And I've been present a number of times where a official looking for a way to shut down a show looks at the lasers. Any paperwork helps.
    All during college, I ran around helping varianced laserists. Every time I'm unemployed or business is slow, I do the same.

    Jeeze, its what, a day of your time to file the paperworK?

    Next you'll tell me doing shows without insurance is just fine, as no insurance company would possibly cover all your liabilities.

    The words here are RISK MITIGATION.

    If you have the paperwork, when it comes down to the lawyers, they then have a tool to negotiate. If you have the paperwork, and a idiot starts flashing a 250 mW pointer around the rave, you can get the pointer shut down. And oh, BTW, if a hot pointer is at your gig, it is your responsibility to let the client know it needs to go. And it does need to go. Its your a$$ if it doesn't.

    Or a client books two laser acts at a gig, the other guy audience scans, you don't, who's got the higher ground now??

    This happens all the time to my friend and sometimes business partner.
    Lighting guys show up with truss mounted 200-300 mW P.O.S. and let it flail on auto all night. Its now right in his show rider and contract, no other non varianced lasers. considering he is a premier act in his area, that means something.

    Oh, and AZ rad safety inspects him frequently and goes to raves looking for lasers.

    And laser safety could get tossed to Homeland any day after one big incident. Those who have paperwork will get grandfathered. Those who don't will see power delegated to local law enforcement, who WILL get a memo on it.

    A example from one of my favorite lawyer movies:

    Lawyer, "Imagine you put Jesus Christ on the witness stand..."
    " Mr Christ , have you been seen in the company of a known prostitute.???"
    Jesus, "well, yes, but I was ..."
    Lawyer, cuts him off in mid answer " Just answer the question,, Yes or NO, Mr Christ ???"

    Roughly quoted From Adam's Rib.




    Here's the scheme:

    You do a show at a bar.
    Ambulance Chasing Lawyer, "your clients lazzor thingie zapped my clients eye, I own you!" "Oh really", says your lawyer, "My client was in complete compliance with the law, Prove otherwise, and prove your client didn't hit his head on the dashboard on the way home"

    Ambulance chaser who can't afford a expert goes to next ambulance.
    Knowing that a jury will tend to favor the licensed, insured, person."

    "Yes or No, Mr Flecom, did you know you needed a variance?"

    And one other thing that has happened to my pal more then once. A venue gets shut down or goes broke. The Sheriff seals the place. My Pal cant recover his gear because they just tossed him out. Guess what gets him his gear back, or in some cases, when a rave is shut down, gets him back in the venue long enough to tear down. It does happen. Law Enforcement understands and tends to respect paperwork. And yes, there have been times when he could not get his gear back for a month when a landlord popped the lease.

    Steve
    Last edited by mixedgas; 11-10-2009 at 08:29.
    Qui habet Christos, habet Vitam!
    I should have rented the space under my name for advertising.
    When I still could have...

  6. #56
    Join Date
    Jan 2009
    Posts
    1,622

    Default

    OK, so what we need is a DETAILED run down of EXACTLY what we need to do to become fully legal. It's great to know the possible ramifications for not following a jumbled and nearly unintelligible (at least to normal folks) set of requirements. If it's so easy, why can't it be simply explained?

    I spent several hours recently reading over the CDRH website, and frankly I got lost in it. The parts pertaining to variances is nearly impossible to follow (much like all gov't paperwork) and I really feel like there should be a concise list of what exactly a person should do from start to finish.

    My main problem is that I don't know where to start.. If the government is so worried about people following their rules, then to me it's the least they could do to make them easily understood.

  7. #57
    Join Date
    Apr 2006
    Location
    Miami, FL
    Posts
    3,590

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by mixedgas View Post
    I can tell you've never worked for a amusement park or a major tour, a variance is a legal requirement and you WILL meet the requirements.
    I think I said MULTIPLE times in this thread that I do not, and do not plan on doing commercial shows. so I am providing an "outsiders" point of view as someone that works with various licensed services that can be equally/if not more dangerous than lasers


    Quote Originally Posted by mixedgas View Post
    You do a show at a bar.
    Ambulance Chasing Lawyer, "your clients lazzor thingie zapped my clients eye, I own you!" "Oh really", says your lawyer, "My client was in complete compliance with the law, Prove otherwise, and prove your client didn't hit his head on the dashboard on the way home"

    Ambulance chaser who can't afford a expert goes to next ambulance.
    Knowing that a jury will tend to favor the licensed, insured, person."
    your thinking of a criminal case where you are innocent until proven guilty... if you are sued you are in civil court, where you are basically guilty until proven innocent...

  8. #58
    Join Date
    Apr 2006
    Location
    Miami, FL
    Posts
    3,590

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by ElektroFreak View Post
    OK, so what we need is a DETAILED run down of EXACTLY what we need to do to become fully legal. It's great to know the possible ramifications for not following a jumbled and nearly unintelligible (at least to normal folks) set of requirements. If it's so easy, why can't it be simply explained?

    I spent several hours recently reading over the CDRH website, and frankly I got lost in it. The parts pertaining to variances is nearly impossible to follow (much like all gov't paperwork) and I really feel like there should be a concise list of what exactly a person should do from start to finish.

    My main problem is that I don't know where to start.. If the government is so worried about people following their rules, then to me it's the least they could do to make them easily understood.
    thats basically what I was trying to say earlier in the thread... why do people not go legal? becuase if they even try they generally give up... I looked into certifying my projector and very quickly gave up

  9. #59
    Join Date
    Jan 2006
    Location
    Charleston, SC
    Posts
    2,147,489,573

    Smile

    Quote Originally Posted by ElektroFreak View Post
    I spent several hours recently reading over the CDRH website, and frankly I got lost in it. The parts pertaining to variances is nearly impossible to follow (much like all gov't paperwork) and I really feel like there should be a concise list of what exactly a person should do from start to finish.
    That would be nice, but it would also be a lot of work. I don't know that any one person has that sort of time to put together such a document, valuable though it might be.

    21 CFR 1040 isn't *that* difficult to follow. It is confusing at the beginning of 1040.10 because they have so many definitions, but once you get past those, the regulations are spelled out pretty clearly. You have to take it slow and be mindful of the outline numbers and letters to know where you are.

    My main problem is that I don't know where to start.
    I would suggest starting by filling out the "guide to filing a Laser Product Report". (See the link that Gottaluvlasers posted in this thread.) Granted, it's a 34 page document, but each question addresses a specific requirement. Broken down that way, it's not that hard to follow. (But it is time-consuming to fill it all out.)
    If the government is so worried about people following their rules, then to me it's the least they could do to make them easily understood.
    Ever file a tax return? The Government has it's own language when it comes to forms, and it always seems to be needlessly complicated. But we're stuck with what we have, at least for now. (There is a movement in the CDRH to make things easier, but it's one of probably a hundred items on their "to do" list, and they don't have the funding to accomplish everything...)

    Adam

  10. #60
    Join Date
    Jan 2009
    Posts
    1,622

    Default

    ^That's why most people hire a tax service.. you get more money back anyway..

    I don't mind taking some time to fill everything out, but I really don't feel that there is anything wrong with the idea of having a thread here (which I have already started) in which people who have experiences that they are willing to share can do so. It's not because we're lazy that we're asking, it's because we're confused and all the info on the subject that is here is scattered all about.. Rather than complaining about people's views regarding doing shows without variances, I feel it would be far more helpful to give some pointers and help to other American laser enthusiasts regarding the variance process so that they can become legal. If they're like me it's not that they don't want to be legal, it's that becoming legal is a very difficult to understand process... If the amateur radio community is willing to do things like this to help aspiring hams, why can't the laser community do the same? I can't think of a single reason. Whenever anyone has ever asked me how to become a licensed amateur radio operator, I have provided them with as many resources as I could to help simplify the process. That's all I'm suggesting the laser community as a whole do for US laser hobbyists. Sure it would be a lot of work, and there's no reason why only one person should have to do it or that it be a single document. That's why I started the variance thread.

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •