Results 1 to 7 of 7

Thread: VERY noisy Galvos...

  1. #1
    Join Date
    Jun 2010
    Location
    Syracuse, NY
    Posts
    287

    Default VERY noisy Galvos...

    I've recently got my first homemade projector beaming and so far I only have one complaint... the galvos are EXTREMELY noisy. I know my first problem is that they are a cheap set of chinese galvos so I guess I can't complain too much for the amount I paid for them. IIRC they are 20kpps scanners I got off Ebay. Although I did not get them from Omar on this forum I did notice that the set I bought looked IDENTICAL to a set of 20kpps scanners he was selling here, for about the same price. I have not tweaked any of the pots on the amps so I can only think of a couple things they may be the cause or at least contributing. This set sat around on my table for probably over a year, they got moved around a bit for another year or so after that but I don't ever remember any rough handling of them. Now that they are in the projector I am noticing that all of the graphics are upside down. While I thought I was being very careful about which wires went where it does appear that I got something backwards, although they still do scan the image fine so I don't believe this is contributing to the noisy at all but I could be wrong. The only other thing I can think of is that I haven't personally tied and ground wires together, I have only connected what wires were provided to me (scanners to amps, amps to PSU and amps to Dave's ILDA interface board). Is there possibly some sort of grounding issue I should be paying particular attention to that maybe wasn't apparent by just plugging in the wires to their respective connectors? Does anyone else out there have a set of 20kpps scanners from Omar that could chime in with their experience? I will admit that I may be over driving them a tad.. I have the default settings in Quickshow set to 15kpps but I do turn the scan rate slider up to 200% for some displays but there is still a noticeable noise even at normal 100% scan. I have cheap chinese projector as well with a cheap set of scanners in it, althoughh I dont know what they are rated for I have a very hard time believing they are even 20kpps scanners since i only spent a little over $400 for the whole projector, and this unit is DEAD silent even when scanning at 200% of 15kpps. any ideas or suggestions I can check to see what might be causing all the noise? Maybe they are just a bad set, who knows. I guess it's not so bad as long as I turn the music up
    LASERS!!

    1x Homemade 500mW 405nm Projector
    1x Homemade 1.2W RGB Projector
    1x Lightspace Color Ray Series 6W RGB
    2x Lightspace Venus 2W RGB

    ZPL Lighting www.zpllighting.com

  2. #2
    Join Date
    Apr 2007
    Location
    Costa Rica
    Posts
    523

    Default

    You say "they still do scan the image fine". If they scan a good test pattern I wouldn't worry about the audible noise (unless they are squealing when stopped and not scanning). Well-tuned scanners can be loud. If the noise is visible in the distorted image, then you have a problem.

  3. #3
    swamidog's Avatar
    swamidog is offline Jr. Woodchuckington Janitor III, Esq.
    Join Date
    Nov 2006
    Location
    santa fe, nm
    Posts
    1,545,835

    Default

    if your projection is upside down, then you either have things wired wrongly or you have the y-axis inverted in software. it's pretty easy to flip a connection when you're wiring things. especially if you're using breakout boards and/or building your own connectors.

    glavos are noisy. think of them as really inefficient speakers. if you're referring to electrical noise in the scanned image, that could certainly be caused by a grounding problem.

    Quote Originally Posted by ZeroPoint View Post
    I've recently got my first homemade projector beaming and so far I only have one complaint... the galvos are EXTREMELY noisy. I know my first problem is that they are a cheap set of chinese galvos so I guess I can't complain too much for the amount I paid for them. IIRC they are 20kpps
    scanners I got off Ebay. Although I did not get them from Omar on this forum I did notice that the set I bought looked IDENTICAL to a set of 20kpps scanners he was selling here, for about the same price. I have not tweaked any of the pots on the amps so I can only think of a couple things they may be the cause or at least contributing. This set sat around on my table for probably over a year, they got moved around a bit for another year or so after that but I don't ever remember any rough handling of them. Now that they are in the projector I am noticing that all of the graphics are upside down. While I thought I was being very careful about which wires went where it does appear that I got something backwards, although they still do scan the image fine so I don't believe this is contributing to the noisy at all but I could be wrong. The only other thing I can think of is that I haven't personally tied and ground wires together, I have only connected what wires were provided to me (scanners to amps, amps to PSU and amps to Dave's ILDA interface board). Is there possibly some sort of grounding issue I should be paying particular attention to that maybe wasn't apparent by just plugging in the wires to their respective connectors? Does anyone else out there have a set of 20kpps scanners from Omar that could chime in with their experience? I will admit that I may be over driving them a tad.. I have the default settings in Quickshow set to 15kpps but I do turn the scan rate slider up to 200% for some displays but there is still a noticeable noise even at normal 100% scan. I have cheap chinese projector as well with a cheap set of scanners in it, althoughh I dont know what they are rated for I have a very hard time believing they are even 20kpps scanners since i only spent a little over $400 for the whole projector, and this unit is DEAD silent even when scanning at 200% of 15kpps. any ideas or suggestions I can check to see what might be causing all the noise? Maybe they are just a bad set, who knows. I guess it's not so bad as long as I turn the music up
    suppose you're thinkin' about a plate o' shrimp. Suddenly someone'll say, like, plate, or shrimp, or plate o' shrimp out of the blue, no explanation. No point in lookin' for one, either. It's all part of a cosmic unconciousness.

  4. #4
    Join Date
    Nov 2007
    Location
    SoCal / San Salvador / NY
    Posts
    4,018

    Default

    hey ZP -

    Quote Originally Posted by ZeroPoint View Post
    ...the galvos are EXTREMELY noisy.
    ...Can you post a quickie vid-clip, so we'z can-all understand your 'definition of EXTREMELY', here?

    Quote Originally Posted by ZeroPoint View Post
    Is there possibly some sort of grounding issue...
    Study / trace-out what you've done, vs this:

    DC Proj Wiring.jpg... and post yer kvestions.. Then 'PL-Think'TM will take-over, and you should be able to vet this out in a jiff..

    Dos colones..
    j
    ....and armed only with his trusty 21 Zorgawatt KTiOPO4...

  5. #5
    Join Date
    Nov 2007
    Location
    Cairns, Australia
    Posts
    1,896

    Default

    Usually you don't need to oil scanners, though it really can't hurt either. Get some fine machine oil, and put a tiny drop of it on the end of something you can apply it around the bearing. Usually the cheap scanners use sleeve bearings, they could get a bit noisy if they're dry.

    I wouldn't be overdriving cheap scanners to start with though, last set I had could barely hold themselves together at their rated speed, let alone higher. You might get away with it on quality sets, but not the cheap ones.

  6. #6
    Join Date
    May 2008
    Location
    Australia
    Posts
    380

    Default

    How do you truly know the speed of you scanners? if the chinese say that its got a 40 k scanner they could lie and put in a cheaper one how would you know? Is there a way to find the true speed of it please explain how???
    Photonlexicon FTP Server.


  7. #7
    Join Date
    Jun 2010
    Location
    Syracuse, NY
    Posts
    287

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by Photonbeam View Post
    You say "they still do scan the image fine". If they scan a good test pattern I wouldn't worry about the audible noise (unless they are squealing when stopped and not scanning). Well-tuned scanners can be loud. If the noise is visible in the distorted image, then you have a problem.
    .

    Yeah, I'm thinking that it is just the way the scanners are. The only set I have to compare it to is the set in my cheap Chinese projector. I'm still amazed at how quiet the Chinese one is even when over-driven, although the "noisy" set definitely a MUCH better and more crisp image even at higher scan speeds.

    Quote Originally Posted by swamidog View Post
    if your projection is upside down, then you either have things wired wrongly or you have the y-axis inverted in software. it's pretty easy to flip a connection when you're wiring things. especially if you're using breakout boards and/or building your own connectors.
    I'm pretty sure I have some wires swapped somewhere. I do have the image inverted in the software now but that is only to make it right side up. I did make my own connectors, or at least a couple of them, so I'll just take a look at what I did. I suppose its not that big of a deal either way. It actually gives a nice effect when I have to two projectors coupled together because they project mirror images of eachother. It looks great for beam effects but throws off any animations.

    Quote Originally Posted by dsli_jon View Post
    hey ZP -



    ...Can you post a quickie vid-clip, so we'z can-all understand your 'definition of EXTREMELY', here?
    Here is a quick video. The QS software is set to 100% of 15kpps which is 5kpps less than the supposed rating of 20kpps. The distortion in the bottom left corner of the test frames is from the display hitting my bed, not because of the projector. The test frames actually look really nice. In one of them there are a couple lines that don't trace each other perfectly but it's pretty close. I didn't increase the scan rate to 150% (150% seems to give the best balance of noise:flicker) in the video but just picture the same sound only slightly louder and of a slightly higher pitch. Also, It doesn't seem quite as loud in the video as it does in person but I'm starting to think that it's not as much of an issue as I originally thought it was. Here's the video anyway. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BDpt9...Syi0IQ&index=1

    Quote Originally Posted by Things View Post
    Usually you don't need to oil scanners, though it really can't hurt either. Get some fine machine oil, and put a tiny drop of it on the end of something you can apply it around the bearing. Usually the cheap scanners use sleeve bearings, they could get a bit noisy if they're dry.

    I wouldn't be overdriving cheap scanners to start with though, last set I had could barely hold themselves together at their rated speed, let alone higher. You might get away with it on quality sets, but not the cheap ones.
    I may attempt to oil them in the future but right now I won't press my luck trying to mess with them.

    Quote Originally Posted by tony220171 View Post
    How do you truly know the speed of you scanners? if the chinese say that its got a 40 k scanner they could lie and put in a cheaper one how would you know? Is there a way to find the true speed of it please explain how???
    My guess would be to run the test frames at various scan rates to determine when the image starts to fall apart. Whatever the max speed the scanners can handle without starting to distort the image would be roughly what they are rated for.
    Last edited by ZeroPoint; 05-22-2013 at 04:48.
    LASERS!!

    1x Homemade 500mW 405nm Projector
    1x Homemade 1.2W RGB Projector
    1x Lightspace Color Ray Series 6W RGB
    2x Lightspace Venus 2W RGB

    ZPL Lighting www.zpllighting.com

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •