Page 2 of 4 FirstFirst 1234 LastLast
Results 11 to 20 of 34

Thread: pangolin safety lense?

  1. #11
    Join Date
    Feb 2008
    Location
    East Sussex, England
    Posts
    5,248

    Default

    MPE is 2.5mW/cm2 which equates to a measurement of 1mW through a 7mm diameter circular aperture - reasonably assumed to be the size of a human dilated pupil.
    Note that the beam must fully fill the sensor.

    Pi*r^2

    3.1415 * (3.5mm^2) = 38.5mm^2

    2.5mW * 0.385 = 0.96mW (or thereabouts)


    My meter sensor is 8x8mm (64mm^2) so 1.6mW is my measured limit in the absence of any other control to limit maximum exposure, such as a scanfail.

    250ms is assumed to be the maximum exposure time, based on the aversion response (blinking/looking away), but if you can control this by other means, and significantly reduce it, then you can use multiples of MPE.



    But this is just skimming the surface really, you need to explore this i far more depth than I've got time to regurgitate right now. I agree, James Stewarts LVR safety course is really very good, although I must say that I had a really solid grounding in what was involved from reading this forum, so you can pick up a lot here.
    Frikkin Lasers
    http://www.frikkinlasers.co.uk

    You are using Bonetti's defense against me, ah?

    I thought it fitting, considering the rocky terrain.

  2. #12
    Join Date
    Aug 2013
    Location
    West Sussex
    Posts
    1,279

    Default

    Thanks Norty. That clears things up for me a bit. More reading to be done I think <gets manual out>

  3. #13
    Join Date
    Mar 2006
    Posts
    2,478

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by norty303 View Post
    MPE is 2.5mW/cm2 which equates to a measurement of 1mW through a 7mm diameter circular aperture - reasonably assumed to be the size of a human dilated pupil.
    Note that the beam must fully fill the sensor.
    I was going to edit my post to mention that 7mm diameter aperture having remembered it a minute or two ago, but you got there first. We must be very careful how we apply those 7 mm, because it isn't the area which matters, so much as the power density that uses it as part of its mathematical expression.

    Case in point: If my earlier question had been (wrongly) resolved to 49 square mm (7mm squared), then as 1 cm squared is 100 square mm, 1mW could be safe only if evenly lighting no less than 40 square mm. Close, and actually safer at 49, but wrong. It might easily have been wrong the other way.

    I sold my Lasercheck over a year ago but I think it had a bigger aperture, at least 8 mm across.
    Last edited by The_Doctor; 01-07-2014 at 13:34.

  4. #14
    Join Date
    Aug 2013
    Location
    West Sussex
    Posts
    1,279

    Default

    Just checked mine - 8mm too. I'd better do some calculations!

    Keith

  5. #15
    Join Date
    Mar 2006
    Posts
    2,478

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by Galvonaut View Post
    Just checked mine - 8mm too. I'd better do some calculations!

    Keith
    Many times... Many, many times... (Round The Horne joke).
    Only way I ever get this stuff is to encounter it often..

  6. #16
    Join Date
    Aug 2013
    Location
    West Sussex
    Posts
    1,279

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by The_Doctor View Post
    Many times... Many, many times... (Round The Horne joke).
    Only way I ever get this stuff is to encounter it often..
    Hehe.

    Yes, that's why I like attempting to teach what I know to others as it helps them (if it's correct) and I learn too, sometimes re-reading, usually re-enforcing . Sometimes I make the odd mistake but there is usually someone here to put me right

    Keith

  7. #17
    Join Date
    Mar 2006
    Posts
    2,478

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by Galvonaut View Post
    Hehe.

    Yes, that's why I like attempting to teach what I know to others as it helps them (if it's correct) and I learn too, sometimes re-reading, usually re-enforcing . Sometimes I make the odd mistake but there is usually someone here to put me right

    Keith
    Nowt wrong there. I think the best teaching is fresh, and it's only really fresh if it's just been learned.

    Solidude, 'waist' is just its narrowest point. Regardless of astigmatism, assymetry, etc, a photon will travel in a straight line. In an ion laser the mirror curvature may put that waist inside or outside the cavity (in front of the output mirror), or a diode laser will have asymmetry of divergence in each of two axes, in which case the waist after lens collimation would be the distance at which cross-sectional area was smallest rather than being the point where the beam was both thinnest and flattest.

    'Inversely proportional' is like the width of a rectangle of fixed area related to its height. If you make one dimension bigger, you have to shrink the other in proportion to preserve the area.

  8. #18
    Join Date
    Aug 2013
    Location
    West Sussex
    Posts
    1,279

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by solidude View Post
    What do you mean by 'it' is safe, you mean the value? Whats the value below which it is safe?
    The beam at a given distance. Well, it is not actually safe. The MPE is a power density that will result in an approximately 3% chance of noticeable injury (if I remember correctly).

    Quote Originally Posted by solidude View Post
    NOHD seems a bit hard to calculate. What is the 'waist of the Gaussian beam'?
    http://www.optique-ingenieur.org/en/...ontenu_09.html
    I doubt that you will be using a Gaussian beam, but you might. The waist is the point at which a beam is focussed to the smallest it can be focussed. It starts diverging (getting bigger) after that.

    Quote Originally Posted by solidude View Post
    (What do you mean by 'inversely proportional'? sorry english is not my main language).
    Inverse square law states that if distance is doubled, the energy density is divided by 4.

    I hope I'm being helpful (and correct)

    Keith

  9. #19
    Join Date
    Apr 2006
    Location
    Orlando, FL - USA
    Posts
    1,770

    Default

    I likely will not see any future replies to this thread, and only saw the word "pangolin" out of the corner of my eye, so I thought I would stop in.

    Quote Originally Posted by Galvonaut View Post
    If you take a measurement of a stationary beam with a Coherent Lasercheck which has a 7mm aperture (same as average pupil size), as long as it does not exceed 1mW, it is 'safe'. The 1mW per 7mm squared figure has a safety factor of 10.
    All of this stuff is based on pretty complicated science. This is an area that I've studied for many years, and in fact have given invited presentations at International Laser Safety conferences, and have patents on products that help ensure that laser shows are safe. It's complicated, but it turns out that there are some simple conclusions that can be drawn, and simple steps that can be taken to ensure that shows are safe.

    First I'd recommend you read my article on audience scanning. It's quite an old article, written in 1997, but comes to some important conclusions toward the end:
    http://www.pangolin.com/resguide09a.htm

    If you want to read a LOT more on the subject, you can do so here:
    http://www.pangolin.com/resguide09b.htm

    If we make the assumption that the LONGEST EXPOSURE you'll ever have is 1 millisecond (not 250 milliseconds as is the case for 2.5mw PER SQUARE CENTIMETER), then the maximum allowable power FOR A STATIC BEAM WHOSE AREA IS AT LEAST ONE SQUARE CENTIMETER would be 10 milliwatts per square centimeter. If you want to use a Laser Check, you can, and I have. But then what you'd want to measure is 5 milliwatts, because 5 milliwatts into a 7mm pupil is roughly the same as 10 milliwatts into a 1 square centimeter area (10 milliwatts per square centimeter).

    If you're going to use the technique finally discussed at the end of my article, then the most important points to remember are:

    1. Always make sure that the beam OVERFILLS the detector area. If the beam is smaller than the detector, then the meter will read in terms of watts, not watts per square centimeter (or AEL if the detector is 7mm).

    2. You'd be measuring a NON-MOVING, NON-MODULATED beam if you want to use this technique. (Also note that I suspect most software in the world will not let you put out a non-modulated beam in the first place -- but ours can).

    Now, getting back to the assumption. If you can guarantee that the maximum exposure is 1 millisecond, then you can get away with single-pulse exposures of 10 milliwatts PER SQUARE CENTIMETER (this is not 10 milliwatts power, but 10 milliwatts per square centimeter -- which could be a whole lot more actual laser power as long as the beam is larger than one square centimeter).

    HOW you would "guarantee" this is with a scan-fail safeguard (a good one, fast enough to respond within a maximum of 1 millisecond). Normal show content that is made for audience scanning should not cause exposures greater than this in the first place, and so the scan fail safeguard would largely do nothing as long as there is not a problem.

    Now, let's NOT assume that the exposure is only 1 millisecond, and let's say that things go drastically wrong. The beam comes to a complete and permanent stop in the audience and lands on someone's eye. Well in that case AS LONG AS THE BEAM IS NO GREATER THAN 10 MILLIWATTS PER SQUARE CENTIMETER, you're not in too much trouble BECAUSE 10 milliwatts per square centimeter is only four times the MPE for a quarter second exposure. In a quarter second, you can blink (close your eyes) which will protect your vision. AND (here's the really important and clever part) 10 milliwatts per square centimeter is within Class 3 R limits. Basically, it's not all that dangerous...

    Remember that the MPE already has a 20X safety limit built in. 10X because at the MPE you are 1/10 the power level that biological studies determined created a 50% LIKELIHOOD of a "minimal lesion" and 2x the 10X because it was only a 50% likelihood. So if you're a few times the MPE, there's still a pretty small chance that there will be permanent damage.

    (Plus there's the fact that audience scanning laser shows have been taking place for 40 years, only within the last decade has there been any attention to safety, and yet we don't have hospitals or nursing homes filled with people blinded by seeing laser shows. So...)

    Remember a few points. David Sliney (the guy who did all of the biological studies on which the MPE is based) stated that "Looking into a 5mW laser beam is exactly the same as looking into the sun"! Every mom tells their child don't look into the sun, but babies and dogs do it all the time. Why isn't everyone blind? Because as soon as you look into the sun, your natural aversion response will force you to turn your head or close your eyes to "avert" the problem. Same thing with a 5mW laser. As long as you do not "override" your aversion response, you'll be fine.

    5mW into a 7mm pupil has exactly the same impact as 10mW PER SQUARE CENTIMETER. That's why so many safety people have come to this same conclusion on this number.

    Now, how do you get to 10 mW PER SQUARE CENTIMETER when using lasers that have many more milliwatts or even watts worth of power? Well, that's where our lenses come into play...

    And with that, I'll leave it to you guys.

    AHA one more thing. This video might help -- at least a little. It doesn't get into any technical details, but talks about a few software and hardware items, as well as the information available on our web site and where to find it: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pohPyDRsCRk

    Bill
    Last edited by Pangolin; 01-08-2014 at 02:20. Reason: Added video link

  10. #20
    Join Date
    Aug 2013
    Location
    West Sussex
    Posts
    1,279

    Default

    Thank you Bill. Great information

    Keith

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •