Page 3 of 4 FirstFirst 1234 LastLast
Results 21 to 30 of 34

Thread: pangolin safety lense?

  1. #21
    Join Date
    Mar 2007
    Location
    UK
    Posts
    244

    Default

    To help reinforce the answers others have given to the OP, the safety limits for laser light exposure are quoted in either 'power per area' (irradiance) or 'energy per area' (radiant exposure). For ease of simplified measurement, it is often more convenient to consider exposure in terms of the first quantity, 'irradiance'. (the way to remember what 'irradiance' is, is to think 'power density'; i.e. how strong the light is concentrated on a particular area)

    What the Pangolin Safety Lenses do is alter (weaken) the power density of laser beams passing through them, not the power. Different strengths of lens can be used to vary how much the original beam is modified. The lens is a semicircle, so that it can be used on a single laser projector output window to modify the lower half, (usually), of the scan field area. i.e. the bit where the spectators are present.

    Why not just modify the whole output window? Well you could, and Pangolin do offer a complete circle lens option now as well. But because the lens increases the spread of the beam achieve the lower power density, the resulting beam can look fatter and fuzzier, loosing the crispness that people associate with lasers. So it is often desirable to have tight unmodified beams overhead, and just modify the beams that can hit the spectators.

    So to outline the process required to check if exposure will be safe you have to:

    Decide on the 'applicable MPE', which is a maximum power density that is permitted.
    Check the exposure using a meter at the closest point of contact with spectators, and adjust with the lens to have a power density reading lower than the MPE limit.

    To perform step 2, it is easiest to do this, (instrumentation wise), with a laser power meter designed to measure stationary beams, which is why it useful to convert the MPE exposure limits to irradiance, (power density).

    Adjusting the power density of a laser beam by increasing its size is far more effective than just adjusting it by turning the power down.

    Norty was correct in saying that value for the limit is 2.5mW per square centimetre, 'in the absence of any other controls' - this is important. And I therefore want to reemphasise the point made earlier by others. If you do not have a scan-fail that can limit the output, then you cannot justify using higher irradiance than 2.5mW per square centimetre. In fact the UK guidance on the issue states that in the case of persons likely to under the influence of alcohol or drugs, a more conservative limit of 1mW per square centimetre should be used as the limit. This is because these people will not have a normal aversion response, so this can't be relied upon as a way of controlling exposure duration.

    The continuous exposure limits noted above are consistent with IEC's international guidance for laser show safety (IEC/TR 60825-3:2008), that was primarily authored by John O'Hagan with the assistance of ILDA, and published in 2008.

    So in terms of power through a 7mm circular aperture, we are still talking about a 1mW 'power' reading being the equivalent to a 2.5mW per square centimetre irradiance. And similarly, 0.38mW being the equivalent to a 1.0mW per square centimetre irradiance.

    (The latest laser safety limits published by ICNIRP now additionally state the visible MPE in terms of the 7mm aperture as it's such a useful way to quote MPE. It overcomes the IEC-ANSI difference in quoting 'per m' and 'per cm', which can cause some further confusion. I've used the 'per cm' units in this post to be consistent with earlier posts in the thread, but virtually everywhere outside of the US uses 'per m'. 25.4W per square metre is the same as 2.5mW per square centimetre)

    The MPE is not a fixed figure, it is time dependent, so the shorter amount of time you are exposed to light, the more light you can be exposed to. Conversely, if you are are exposed to light for longer periods, the amount of light you can be exposed to decreases. Only if there scanning safeguard present should greater irradiance values be applied.

    As Bill has stated, if exposures can be assured to be less than 1ms in duration, then a valid argument can be made to defend the use of the higher MPE.

    However, it may seem fine to say that a scanning failure of a scanning beam that has its light limited to a fixed maximum irradiance, only exceeds the MPE by 4x etc in the case of a drastic scanner movement failure. But from my experience with venues and insurance companies, they are not interested in 'any' MPE excess being a possibility.

    Science and risk aside, the key figure is the excess. Being 4x or 10x above the legal limit sounds bad in an insurance claim or court room. End of. Especially if what lead to the exposure goes against published international guidance on the subject, or poor safety control measures. The organisations I have in my work portfolio would not be interested in being in position where they are having to defend even a 4x the limit claim. Such a situation makes it easy pickings for a claimant seeking compensation, likely resulting in an out of court settlement by the insurance company. - this is not speculation, I've seen, firsthand, this happen when an organisation's lack of controls, have lead to a strong likelihood of exposure levels being exceeded.

    So, while Bill is right to state that a 5mW reading is acceptable on a Lasercheck, it must always be used with a good robust scanning health monitor, that can limit duration. To be defendable, this should be something that monitors more than just scanner velocity. And really, when using increased light levels that push the extent of the shorter exposures, to get brighter beams, greater care has to be taken to make sure the limits are not being exceeded.

    The limits are one thing, but for some time, more recently, John O'Hagan has been expressing concerns about deliberate spectator exposure, and has evidence to suggest that a further, (reducing), correction factor should be applied to account for visual disturbance from direct ocular exposure. This was a hot topic discussed at last year's ILSC meeting, and I guess will continue as time moves on.

    One thing with laser safety is that it is a fluid subject, and as scientific knowledge grows, the limits and how exposures are considered evolve too. Hence the reason for the exposure limits being updated last year, and finding their way into the safety standards due to be published shortly.

    Hopefully this has helped to answer the OP's question, and to provide some more detail to others that are interested in this topic and the rationale for the figures being quoted.

    James
    Last edited by JStewart; 01-09-2014 at 01:55. Reason: typo
    Laser Safety
    https://www.lvroptical.com
    https://www.facebook.com/LaserSafety

    - Laser Show Safety Training & Audience Scanning Workshops.
    - Effects Assessment, and Realtime MPE Measurement
    - Pangolin PASS System Integrator

  2. #22
    Join Date
    Aug 2013
    Location
    West Sussex
    Posts
    1,279

    Default

    Very useful, thank you James

    Keith

  3. #23
    Join Date
    Aug 2008
    Location
    UK
    Posts
    5,704

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by JStewart View Post

    The limits are one thing, but for some time, more recently, John O'Hagan has been expressing concerns about deliberate spectator exposure, and has evidence to suggest that a further, (reducing), correction factor should be applied to account for visual disturbance from direct ocular exposure. This was a hot topic discussed at last year's ILSC meeting, and I guess will continue as time moves on.
    So much for an industry supposedly progressing based on science towards a 10X MPE limit. The evidence of 40 years supports (tentatively) the safety of a 10x higher limit so the powers that be in the UK take us backwards. It appears JOH is leading us towards a complete ban.

    James, is this some obscure H&S concern that maybe someone will trip during a millisecond of dazzle? If that's the case surely they should ban strobes and bright moving head fixtures as well!

  4. #24
    Join Date
    Mar 2006
    Posts
    2,478

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by Pangolin View Post
    5mW into a 7mm pupil has exactly the same impact as 10mW PER SQUARE CENTIMETER. That's why so many safety people have come to this same conclusion on this number.
    If the 7mm 'pupil' width were square that would be 49 square mm, so damn close to half the 100 square mm in one square cm, but by PI*Rsquared for a 7mm diameter circle I get 38.485 square mm which is a lot less than half, so I'm still confused. On the other hand, a Lasercheck sensor is actually 8mm, which by same formula is 50.265 square mm so that really IS half, so 5mW filling the whole sensor area really will measure correctly. But this begs the question of why that 7mm figure even exists, if used this way, unless that 7mm wide aperture were square and not round.

    I got most of the text though, and I understand that a safety lens by diverging the beam allows more power total for higher brightness while not giving anyone too much for the crucial 1ms.

    Incidentally, a lot of people talk of slow scanners being ok for beam shows, but the faster the better, surely, as that's a good way to keep exposure time low and allow more power, even without diverging the beam, so long as a scanfail system can cope with the speed.

    EDIT:
    james said this:
    So in terms of power through a 7mm circular aperture, we are still talking about a 1mW 'power' reading being the equivalent to a 2.5mW per square irradiance. And similarly, 0.38mW being the equivalent to a 1.0mW per square irradiance.
    This fits. I suspect that there may be some confusion at times, expert or non-expert, between which size is used. 7mm dia gives ratio of roughly 1:2.5 while 8mm (as with Lasercheck) gives very close to 1:2, but it seems to me that these different rations to 1 cm2 can trip up almost anyone at any time. Devil in the detail, etc....
    Last edited by The_Doctor; 01-08-2014 at 08:17.

  5. #25
    Join Date
    Feb 2008
    Location
    East Sussex, England
    Posts
    5,248

    Default

    Incidentally, a lot of people talk of slow scanners being ok for beam shows, but the faster the better,
    'Slow' is relative. I do most beam shows around 18k which is a lot slower than 30k, but the beam is still moving very quickly.
    I hear so many people say that they are safe 'because they are scanning at 30k' and at the same time be completely ignorant of what happens in a fault condition, which is what we are essentially doing this for. The worst case scenario.
    Last edited by norty303; 01-08-2014 at 09:06.
    Frikkin Lasers
    http://www.frikkinlasers.co.uk

    You are using Bonetti's defense against me, ah?

    I thought it fitting, considering the rocky terrain.

  6. #26
    Join Date
    Mar 2006
    Posts
    2,478

    Default

    Point taken. I've learned not to talk this notion except in the context of a scanfail system included...

  7. #27
    Join Date
    Feb 2008
    Location
    East Sussex, England
    Posts
    5,248

    Default

    Even in the context of a fast scanfail, a 'slow' scan is still going to be faster than the scanfail speed (assuming no silly patterns, hotspots are used in the crowd, as we all know we shouldn't do, right? )
    Frikkin Lasers
    http://www.frikkinlasers.co.uk

    You are using Bonetti's defense against me, ah?

    I thought it fitting, considering the rocky terrain.

  8. #28
    Join Date
    Mar 2006
    Posts
    2,478

    Default

    Well, 18K makes a very short dwell time beyond a few feet, but some scanfails are really fast now. I did look at the calculations once, but only once, and forgot the detail because it's not a thing I needed to know beyond curiosity at the time.

    Given what James said about energy rather than irradiance as the other way MPE is measured, that quest for the ideal MPE meter, and the quest for the perfect scanfail, are basically the same quest.

  9. #29
    Join Date
    Feb 2008
    Location
    East Sussex, England
    Posts
    5,248

    Default

    Pangolin PASS is generally considered to be one of the better products on the market, certainly regarding speed of response.
    This is and excert from the manual regarding the dwell time setting.
    Whilst it is possible to have faster than 1ms response, I think that impact on genuine patterns may be too adversely affected.

    The Dwell Time controls the time that a beam may remain at or
    below the minimum velocity, before PASS extinguishes the beam.
    At the factory, Pangolin sets this to around 1.5 milliseconds. We
    have found that a combination of 5 radians per second, and 1.5
    millisecond Dwell Time provides a good degree of safety, while
    not negatively impacting normal show programming. Turning this
    control counter-clockwise reduces the Dwell Time, and turning this
    control clockwise increases it. The Dwell Time can be adjusted
    between approximately 100 microseconds and 10 milliseconds.
    Frikkin Lasers
    http://www.frikkinlasers.co.uk

    You are using Bonetti's defense against me, ah?

    I thought it fitting, considering the rocky terrain.

  10. #30
    Join Date
    Mar 2006
    Posts
    2,478

    Default

    Ok. And I note that 100µs is possible for PASS... So long as a scanfail was capable of being fast enough to interfere with a safe scan speed, then increasing total speed and decreasing corner point time or blanking at such moments can allow a brighter show with or without the safetyscan lens, with the lens being an extra safe boost to visibility. I just think that this must always be examined in context. Many means are viable together, I think the problem is that people may tend to rely on just one or two.

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •